eh imports
60a Queen Street, Glasgow, United Kingdom
Buy g-star, diesel, armani apparel
C-35 Rampuri Near Surya Nagar, ; Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh, India
91 120 2624523
Fuel filler necks, side view mirror, hose clamp, sheet metal parts, seat, radiator/diesel/fuel/gas caps, horns, pulley, fan cover, radiator fan in sheet metal, thermo state, water pump seal
65 Regent Street, London, United Kingdom, United Kingdom
Auto, Cars, Diesel
Auto Diesel Vic, s.a.
Ctra De Manlleu 45, ; Vic, Barcelona, Spain
34 938890375
GPS, diesel, video, mobile, injection, turbo, shock abosrber, MP3
Redcliffe House, Redcliff Road, Hessle, East Yorkshire, United Kingdom
Diesel / Lpg Binary Fuel System

Are Diesel Submarines Still a Good Investment?

Thu, 20 Jan 2022 17:30:00

Key Point: The advent of cheap, stealthy, and long-enduring diesel submarines is yet another factor placing carriers and other expensive surface warships at greater risk when operating close to defended coastlines. Fortunately, this did not occur in actual combat but was simulated as part of a war game pitting a carrier task force including numerous antisubmarine escorts against HSMS Gotland, a small Swedish diesel-powered submarine displacing 1,600 tons. Yet despite making multiple attack runs on the Reagan, the Gotland was never detected.

In 2005, USS Ronald Reagan, a newly constructed $6.2 billion dollar aircraft carrier, sank after being hit by multiple torpedoes.

Fortunately, this did not occur in actual combat but was simulated as part of a war game pitting a carrier task force including numerous antisubmarine escorts against HSMS Gotland, a small Swedish diesel-powered submarine displacing 1,600 tons. Yet despite making multiple attack runs on the Reagan, the Gotland was never detected.

This outcome was replicated time and time again over two years of war games, with opposing destroyers and nuclear attack submarines succumbing to the stealthy Swedish sub. Naval analyst Norman Polmar said the Gotland “ran rings” around the American carrier task force. Another source claimed U.S. antisubmarine specialists were “demoralized” by the experience.

How was the Gotland able to evade the Reagan’s elaborate antisubmarine defenses involving multiple ships and aircraft employing a multitude of sensors? And even more importantly, how was a relatively cheap submarine costing around $100 million—roughly the cost of a single F-35 stealth fighter today—able to accomplish that? After all, the U.S. Navy decommissioned its last diesel submarine in 1990.

Diesel submarines in the past were limited by the need to operate noisy, air-consuming engines that meant they could remain underwater for only a few days before needing to surface. Naturally, a submarine is most vulnerable and can be most easily tracked, when surfaced, even when using a snorkel. Submarines powered by nuclear reactors, on the other hand, do not require large air supplies to operate, and can run much more quietly for months at a time underwater—and they can swim faster while at it.

However, the two-hundred-foot-long Swedish Gotland-class submarines, introduced in 1996, were the first to employ an Air Independent Propulsion (AIP) system—in this case, the Stirling engine. A Stirling engine charges the submarine’s seventy-five-kilowatt battery using liquid oxygen.

With the Stirling, a Gotland-class submarine can remain undersea for up to two weeks sustaining an average speed of six miles per hour—or it can expend its battery power to surge up to twenty-three miles per hour. A conventional diesel engine is used for operation on the surface or while employing the snorkel. The Stirling-powered Gotland runs more quietly than even a nuclear-powered sub, which must employ noise-producing coolant pumps in their reactors.

The Gotland class does possess many other features that make it adept at evading detection. It mounts twenty-seven electromagnets designed to counteract its magnetic signature to Magnetic Anomaly Detectors. Its hull benefits from sonar-resistant coatings, while the tower is made of radar-absorbent materials. Machinery on the interior is coated with rubber acoustic-deadening buffers to minimize detectability by sonar. The Gotland is also exceedingly maneuverable thanks to the combined six maneuvering surfaces on its X-shaped rudder and sail, allowing it to operate close to the sea floor and pull off tight turns.

Because the stealthy boat proved the ultimate challenge to U.S. antisubmarine ships in international exercises, the U.S. Navy leased the Gotland and its crew for two entire years to conduct antisubmarine exercises. The results convinced the U.S. Navy its undersea sensors simply were not up to dealing with the stealthy AIP boats.

However, the Gotland was merely the first of many AIP-powered submarine designs—some with twice the underwater endurance. And Sweden is by no means the only country to be fielding them.

China has two diesel submarine types using Stirling engines. Fifteen of the earlier Type 039A Yuan class have been built in four different variants, with more than twenty more planned or already under construction. Beijing also has a single Type 032 Qing-class vessel that can remain underwater for thirty days. It is believed to be the largest operational diesel submarine in the world and boasts seven Vertical Launch System cells capable of firing off cruise missiles and ballistic missiles.

Russia debuted with the experimental Lada-class Sankt Peterburg, which uses hydrogen fuel cells for powerIt is an evolution of its widely produced Kilo-class submarine. However, sea trials found that the cells provided only half of the expected output, and the type was not approved for production. However, in 2013 the Russian Navy announced it would produce two heavily redesigned Ladas, the Kronstadt and Velikiye Luki, expected by the end of the decade.

Other producers of AIP diesel submarines include Spain, France, Japan, and Germany. These countries have in turn sold them to navies across the world, including to India, Israel, Pakistan, and South Korea. Submarines using AIP systems have evolved into larger, more heavily armed, and more expensive types, including the German Dolphin-class and the French Scorpene-class submarines.

The U.S. Navy has no intention to field diesel submarines again, however, preferring to stick to nuclear submarines that cost multiple billions of dollars. It’s tempting to see that as the Pentagon choosing once again a more expensive weapon system over a vastly more cost-efficient alternative. It’s not quite that simple, however.

Diesel submarines are ideal for patrolling close to friendly shores. But U.S. subs off Asia and Europe need to travel thousands of miles just to get there and then remain deployed for months at a time. A diesel submarine may be able to traverse that distance—but it would then require frequent refueling at sea to complete a long deployment.

Remember the Gotland? It was shipped back to Sweden on a mobile dry dock rather than making the journey on its own power.

Though the new AIP-equipped diesel subs may be able to go weeks without surfacing, that’s still not as good as going months without having to do so. And furthermore, a diesel submarine—with or without AIP—can’t sustain high underwater speeds for very long, unlike a nuclear submarine. A diesel sub will be most effective when ambushing a hostile fleet whose position has already been “cued” by friendly intelligence assets. However, the slow, sustainable underwater speed of AIP-powered diesel submarines make them less than ideal for stalking prey over vast expanses of water.

These limitations don’t pose a problem to diesel subs operating relatively close to friendly bases, defending littoral waters. But while diesel submarines may be great while operating close to home—the U.S. Navy usually doesn’t.

Still, the fact that one could build or acquire three or four diesel submarines costing $500 to $800 million each for the price of a single nuclear submarine gives them undeniable appeal. Proponents argue that the United States could forward deploy diesel subs to bases in allied nations, without facing the political constraints posed by nuclear submarines. Furthermore, advanced diesel submarines might serve as a good counter to an adversary’s stealthy sub fleet.

However, the U.S. Navy is more interested in pursuing the development of unmanned drone submarines. Meanwhile, China is working on long-enduring AIP systems using lithium-ion batteries, and France is developing a new large AIP-equipped diesel submarine version of its Barracuda-class nuclear attack submarine.

The advent of cheap, stealthy, and long-enduring diesel submarines is yet another factor placing carriers and other expensive surface warships at greater risk when operating close to defended coastlines. Diesel submarines benefitting from AIP will serve as a deadly and cost-effective means of defending littoral waters, though whether they will carve out a role for themselves in blue water naval forces operating far from home is less clear.

Sébastien Roblin writes on the technical, historical and political aspects of international security and conflict for publications including The National InterestNBC and War is Boring. He holds a Master’s degree from Georgetown University and served with the Peace Corps in China. You can follow his articles on Twitter. This piece was originally featured in November 2016 and is being republished due to reader's interest.

Image: Reuters.

DTN Diesel-Technologie Nuernberg Aguicu GmbH
Trading Company
Roethensteig 21, Nuernberg, Germany
Diesel, Bosch, Delphi
1661 16th Ave. SW, Naples, Florida, United States
Fuel, gasoline, diesel, auto accessories
S H O Vertriebs- und Betreuungs-GmbH
Woerthstr. 33, ; Gelsenkirchen, Germany
49 209 3616555
Automotive spareparts, motor starters, alternators, lightning systems, diesel
Millard Global Ltd.
Fenchurch, ; London, London, United Kingdom
44 20 79771256
Millard filters for oil, air fuel and cabin. Filtros millard para aceite, aire, gasolina, diesel, combustible y habitaculo o polen
AL Filter
Tchlenov 4, ; Tel Aviv, Israel, Israel
972 3 6880541
Fuel / Diesel / Air / Cabin Filters for the Automotive Industry
1132 Hwy. 190 West, Port Allen, Louisiana, United States
Diesel / Heavy Equipment Repair, Buy & Sell Used Cars, Sell Trucks & Trailers And Other Equipment
Endah Eureka Sdn. Bhd.
Trading Company
No. 1014, Malayan Mansion, Jalan Masjid India, ; Kuala Lumpur, Federal Territory, Malaysia
603 03 26985137
Palm oil products, Diesel, D2, LPG
Biosphere Services
Trading Company
26, Jln Sg. Cincin 27/57, ; Shah Alam, Selangor, Malaysia
60 016 9955668
Urea, diesel, cement
Martin Rivera
Trading Company
4528 Tonopah AVE, San Diego, California, United States
Biodiesel, Diesel, Biod
Artpix, Inc.
936 Rich Place, ; Mountain View, California, United States
1 408 7520100
Diesel, Bio Diesel, Bio Fuel,
ZR Maju Interprise
Trading Company
Sekesyen Bb7, Rawang, Selangor, Malaysia
Trading Company, Agent, Distributor/Wholesaler, Government ministry/Bureau/Commission
Victoria, Bonny, Rivers State, Nigeria
Crude Oil, Diesel, Farm Produce, Petroleum Products,
The Apex Services Group
Business Service (Transportation, finance, travel, Ads, etc)
1101-L Hillcrest Parkway, Dublin, Georgia, United States
Jet Fuel, Diesel, Coal, Jet Aircraft, Coal
NRI Commercial
2627 E Thomas Rd, Phoenix, Arizona, United States
Crude oil, diesel
North Oil Trade
Trading Company
1370 Sw 128 St, ; Miami, Florida, United States
1 305 3781314
D2, diesel, oil
Corporation/Limited Liability Company
1221 Brickell AVE. Suite 900, Miami, United States
Crude Oil, Petroleum Products, Diesel, Nitrogen Fertilizer, Phosphate Fertilizer
APT Sciences
228 Mary Lane Box 399, ; Victoria, Mississippi, United States
1 662 8383902
Diesel, petroleum products
The Iceberg Group
Trading Company
P.O. Box 1815, ; El Segundo , California, United States
1 310 6286613
Diesel, Jet Fuel, Av Gas, crude oil
Cra 9 57-29, ; Bogota, Bogota D. E., Colombia
57 1 2355714
Crude Oil, Diesel, JP
No 7, Imadeyo street off Ewah Road., ; Benin-City, Edo State, Nigeria
234 052 601362
Crude oil, petroleum products such as, fuel oil, diesel, kerosine
34 Lantern St., ; New York, New York, United States
1 631 421-1235
Lpg, fuel oil, diesel,
Reich T. O.
Kvaternikova 32, ; Split, Croatia (local name: Hrvatska)
385 98 602099
Crude oil, gasoline, diesel, fuel oil,
Global Links
Trading Company
126, Capitol Cinema Bldg, Dr. D.N.Rd, Opp CST, Fort, ; Mumbai, Maharashtra, India
91 9820154632
Crude oils, Fuel Oil, Diesel, Bitumen, LPG, Mazut
Trading Company, Agent, Business Service (Transportation, finance, travel, Ads, etc)
303 Sw 120 AVE, P'pines, Florida, United States
Bouake Oil & Mining Market Ltd.
Individual (Sole proprietorship)
04 BP 1325 Abidjan 04, Cote D'ivoire, Abidjan, Cocody, Cote D'ivoire, Abidjan, Cote D'Ivoire
Diesel, Fuel Jet, Plam Oil
Lins Oil Trading Ltd.
Corporation/Limited Liability Company
Rond De Boom 28, Sint Jansteen / Hulst, The Netherlands, Netherlands
Crude Oil, Mazut, Diesel, Jet Fuel, Bio-Diesel
WowGen Petroleum Sdn Bhd
Trading Company
34 Lingkungan Desa Old Klang Road, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
Petroleum Products, Jet Fuel, Mazut M100, Diesel, LNG, LPG, Portland Cement, Sugar
vesneft oil.
LLC (Ltd Liability Corp)
26 Leninskii Prospect, Kop. 5, Moscow, Russian Federation
7-926 -3255161
Mazut-M-100, D2russian Gas, Oil Jet Fuel, REBCO, LPG LNG, Hsp[high Speed, Diesel
JLFK Services Sdn Bhd
Trading Company, Buying Office, Agent, Distributor/Wholesaler
13 Jalan Sudirman 3, Temerloh, Pahang, Malaysia
60-9-296 9760
Chemicals, Diesel, General Trading
Joseph Andre Associates. LLC
LLC (Ltd Liability Corp)
414 Chestnut Avenue, Lindenwold, New Jersey, United States
Crude, Diesel, Decant Oil
Dream Projects
Manufacturer, Trading Company, Buying Office, Agent, Distributor/Wholesaler, Government ministry/Bureau/Commission, Association, Business Service (Tra
Easternjubailindustrial City, Jubail, Eastern, Saudi Arabia
Bitumen, Diesel, Petrol, Hcl, Overhualing, Vibration Analysis
LLC (Ltd Liability Corp)
Tatari 25-110, Tallinn, Estonia
Mettal, Urea, Diesel
Industrias Vega
39 Ave Sur Pje 10# 110 Col. Monserrat, San Salvador, El Salvador
Biodiesel, Diesel
87, Tingkat 1, Lorong Gamelan 3 / 1, Tmn Ria Jaya, Sungai Petani, Kedah, Malaysia
Market Arm
Sungai Long, Kajang, Selangor, Malaysia
Diesel, Gasoline, LPG
5, Pantai Hillpark, Phase 3,, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
Diesel, Crude Oil, Mazut
IBT Bunkering&Trading
Trading Company
Raboisen 32, Hamburg, Germany
Base Oils, Diesel, Lubricants
shree balaji petroleum
Shree Balaji Petroleum, Raigarh, Madhya Pradesh, India
A. H. International Petroleum Energy
Individual (Sole proprietorship)
Hamad Abdulla Road, Captain Building, Fujairah, United Arab Emirates, United Arab Emirates
Fuel Oil, Diesel, Crue Oil, Coal
Trading Company
5575 Beaucourt, Box 17,, ; Montreal, Quebeq, Canada, H3w 2t7, New York, United States
514 807 0290
Crude oil, diesel, jet fuel
Prs Italia
Via Roma, 23 / A, Corsico, Milano, Italy
Diesel, Urea, Cement, Sugar, Scrap Metal, Used Rails, Copper Cathode
335 / 12 Srinakarin Road, Nongbon, Pravet, Bangkok, Bangkok, Thailand
Fuel Oil, Diesel
bekas corporacion
Trading Company
Carr El Plantio, Calle Cerro Del Aire N0. 2 1304, Madrid, Madrid, Spain
Diesel, Iron Fines, Cooper
Dermaga Associate Sdn Bhd
Trading Company
No. 100, Jalan Kapar27 / 89, Megah Indah Industrial, Taman Alam Megah,, Shah Alam, Selangor, Malaysia
Urea, Diesel, Trading
al asrar trading
Trading Company
Deira, Dubai, Dubai, United Arab Emirates
Oil, Diesel
No. 11 & 13, Jalan 19 / 4b, Subang Jaya, Selangor, Malaysia
60-3-5631 1286
Diesel, Liquid Petroleum Gas (LPG) And Bitumen, Fuel Oil
10 Pembury Place, London, United Kingdom
Crude Oil, Diesel, Rubco
Farmers of North America
310 Research Drive, Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, Canada
P. O. Box 175, Anasco, Puerto Rico, Puerto Rico
Diesel, Fuel Oil
Energy P LTD
Trading Company
Weston Gates, Fl, Miami, Florida, United States
Asphalt, Diesel, Jet Fuel
Tmp Investments, LLC
35 Chicory Lane, Covington, Georgia, United States
Crude Oil, Diesel,
Bargac Inc.
173 Almond, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, United States
Crude Oil, Fuel Oil, Diesel
Energy Republic Ltd
Trading Company
18 Upper Brook Street, Mayfair, London, United Kingdom
Crude oils, mazut m100 low less than 0.5% and high sulphur more than 0.5%, jet fuel, lpg, lng, diesel, rebco, slco
Greensaver Resources, LLC
HC67 Box 81, Anton Chico, New Mexico, United States
Gasoline, diesel, fuel saver
Calle 10, Edf. Rianpier, Piso 2, La Urbina, ; Caracas, Miranda, Venezuela
58 212 2419122
Asphalt, diesel, jet fuel
Petroimp International
Ave Samuel Lewis Y Cl 53, Panama, Panama
Urea,crude oil,diesel
Eveready Manufacturing Pte Ltd
32 Tuas South Street 3, ; Singapore
65 68634138
Plastic, base oil, diesel
Hauck GmbH
Trading Company
Sannibal 3, ; Bad Waldsee, Germany
49 173 5656987
Oil, Diesel
Egri Oil Co.
Trading Company
Sok.5 Sult. Egrioilatyahoodotcom, Istanbul, Istanbul, Turkey, Turkey
Diesel, Crude Oil, LPG And Others, Real Estate Partnership
EA Energy
Trading Company, Agent
Amay House Odegbami Close OFF Adeniyi Jones Ikj, Lagos, Lagos, Nigeria
Ago, Lpfo, Diesel, Palm Acid Oil, Palm Oil, Jatropha Oil, Castor Oil, Fish Oil, Olive Oil, Acia Oil
10 Alhaja Toyibat Street, Medina Estate, Gbagada, Lagos, Lagos, Nigeria
Diesel, Bus And Car Rental, Consultancy
136 High Street, Aylesbury, United Kingdom
Petrol, Diesel, Cooking Oil
Rubikon C.A.
Trading Company
Av. La Estancia, Torre Las Mercedes, Ofc. 4b, Piso 4, Caracas, Venezuela, Venezuela
Diesel, Jet Fuel, Crude Oil
Kobac Nig. Ltd
#15 Hospital Rd., Bonny Island, ; Bonny Island, Rivers State, Nigeria
234 084 0835528136
Trading Company
31 Emad Eldeen St., Down Town, Cairo, Egypt
Diesel, spare parts, caterpillar
Micropoint Distribution Sdn Bhd
Trading Company, Agent, Distributor/Wholesaler, Business Service (Transportation, finance, travel, Ads, etc)
B3-10, Plaza Dwitasik, Bandar Sri Permaisuri, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, Malaysia
Oils, Gas, Urea, Diesel, Palm Oil
World-Stop Services
Trading Company
Pasir Ris Dr 4, ; Singapore
65 65852814
Petroleum, palm oil, diesel
Trading Company
C1/1, Ulavar Santhai Road, Anna Nagar, Madurai, Tamil Nadu, India
XXX Primary
As Per Request, Moscow, Russian Federation
7-916 -6703268
Diesel, Mazut, Aviation Kerosine
31a Jalan Rawa Taman Perling, Johor Bahru, Johor Malaysia, Malaysia
Diesel, fuel oil
SkyEvo International
Trading Company
111 North Bridge Road, #27-01 Peninsula Plaza, Singapore
2497 Britt Way, San Jose, California, United States
Mabna Commerce Development
Trading Company
14669-55358 Tehran-Iran, ; Tehran, Tehran, Iran (Islamic Republic of)
0098 21 88095513
Lot Pt 1848 3rd Floor, Wisma Ypk, Jalan Hospital, ; Kota Bharu, Kelantan, Malaysia
60 9 7419606
Diesel, internet advertising, trading, fishing industry
Trading Company
Rm 301 Al Shamsi Bldg Near Bank Of Baroda Al Nakheel Rd / Po Box 12383, Ras Al Khaimah, United Arab Emirates
Base Oils, Finished Lubricants, Bitumen, Fuel Oil, Paraffin Wax, Diesel,
In, 46895, P. O. 50515; , Fort Wayne, Indiana, United States
Fuel Oil, Diesel, Crude Oil
Dasoqi & Deutscher Global
16 Al Horieah St, Sana, Sana, Yemen
Slco, D2, Avgas, Fuel Oil, Bitumen, Diesel, Petroleum, Mazut
81 Viscount Avenue, Winsor East, Randburg, Johannesburg, Gauteng, South Africa
Petroleum Products, Petrol, Diesel, Parafin / Kerosin, Crued Oil
Afrocrude, Inc
Corporation/Limited Liability Company
1001 Pennsylvania Avenue, Washington, DC, United States
Aviation Fuel, Diesel, Crude Oil, Kerosene
B-3136 Lrg Bkt Sekilau 14, Tman Sekilau Maju 2, Kuantan, Pahang, Malaysia
jp.pears intl. ltd
Individual (Sole proprietorship)
# 7 Rivonia Road, Sandton, Johannesburg, Gauteng, South Africa
Crude Oil, Gasoline, Diesel
Trading Company
10 Ubi Crescent #03-72 Ubi Techpark, Singapore
Trade energy commodities such as fuel oil m100, crude oil, diesel, marine fuel oil, naphtha. Trade petrochemicals, such as pta, paraxylene, fertilizers such as granular urea, prilled urea.
Trace Management
Individual (Sole proprietorship)
67, Jalan Utama, KG Melayu Majidee, Johor Bahru, Johor, Malaysia
Diesel, Jetfuel, Kerosene
AP oils
Individual (Sole proprietorship)
20 Army Barrack Road Warri, Warri, Delta, Nigeria
Crude Oil, Petrol, Kerosene, Gas, Diesel
A One Auto Industries
52, Nidhi Society, B / H Satya Sai Hospital, Kalawad Road, Rajkot, Gujarat, India
Three Wheeler, Auto Rickshaws, CNG, Petrol, Diesel
Hwy 77 And Hwy 71, La Grange, Texas, United States
Methanol, Soybean Oil, Diesel
Trading Company
Bakhshi Ave, Malayer, Hammedan, Iran (Islamic Republic of)
Oil Product, Baes Oil, Diesel
No. 5, Felele Rab, Ibadan, Oyo State, Nigeria
Diesel, Supplier
8 Ezebunwo Street Off Faith Av. Woji Road Woji Town Ph, Port Harcourt, Rivers, Nigeria
Diesel, Containers, Palm Oil
Cosmic Array Sdn Bhd
Trading Company
K 9602, Level 1, Taman Chukai Utama, Kemaman, Terengganu, Malaysia, Malaysia
Diesel, D2, Hsd
G 59 Marina Arcade Connaught Place, New Delhi-110001, Delhi, India
Petroleum, Gasoline, Diesel
7340nw174 Terrace Unit 102, Miami Lakes, Florida, United States
Energy, Diesel
254 Jalan Mahkota Taman Maluri Cheras, ; Kuala Lumpur, Wilayah, Malaysia
60 3 9284 4033
Petronas, Diesel, Petroleum
Bolis International, Inc.
Trading Company
8147 Baltimore Ave, College Park, Md, U. S. A., Armenia
Crude Oil, Diesel
No. 1, Jalan Bersatu 19, Taman Bersatu,, Rawang, Selangor, Malaysia, Malaysia
Diesel, Lubricants, Petrol